Isle of Broken Years by Jane Fletcher

Isle of Broken Years

Isle of Broken Years by Jane Fletcher

My rating: 4 of 5 star

I was completely blindsided by this book. I went into this expecting one thing and got a completely different story than I thought it would be. In a very good way! I loved what this story turned out to be. It was interesting, unique, and had a really good cast of characters.

I will say, I really do not think I would consider this book to be a romance. It was more of a mild subplot to something much bigger. I was also a bit disappointed in the ending. I really wish there had been just a bit more to it.

Full Review with Spoilers

This book was such a wild ride! I went into this expecting a pirate story with romance and a twist of some nature. The book started out exactly how I expected, and to be honest, I kept feeling like I had read something similar before. Catalina is Spanish noble woman on her way to marry a man she’s never met, but is taken by pirates and held for ransom. Sam is the cabin boy who is actually hiding her gender because she has no family left and pirate life keeps her off the streets and fed, a plan put into motion by her father before he died. Naturally Sam is smitten and wants to keep Catalina safe from the ruffians. This is entirely what I expect when everything took a complete turn.

Sam and Catalina end up on a strange island they soon realize is Atlantis, created by an alien race a very long time ago. Though time is irrelevant on the island because it jumps through time collecting inhabitants from a varying array of time periods, none of them able to leave again after. I absolutely loved this! It was so different an unexpected. I adore science fiction and this was a nice blend of genres.

There was a very colorful cast of characters as well. The conversations between them were entertaining due to the various styles of speech and understanding. It made for a lot of interesting dynamics between characters as well as the development of the main characters, Sam and Catalina. Though, despite the fact that they where the main characters of the story, I really felt they were more so the catalysts for the story than what the story centered on. It was Catalina’s educated upbringing that allowed them to discover the way off of the island though.

The few issues I had I feel are minor in the grand scheme of things. I did feel like Sam and especially Catalina jumped into the camp of acceptance a wee bit too fast. It seemed a bit too streamlined. The romance also felt like much more of a subplot and realistically, the story didn’t even need it. The plot would not have suffered without it. Catalina’s sudden questioning of her sexuality and interest in Sam was cute, but wasn’t what kept me reading.

The ending was also lackluster. The climatic battle and race against the clock to escape the island before it sunk was enthralling, but once they made it off the story just feels unfinished. Yes the author attempted to give us a glimpse into their lives with an epilogue consisting of fake news articles and emails, but I wanted a little bit more. I do think it would require another book entirely to really explain how each character assimilated to life in the year 2025, but the articles where just too sparse for my taste.

Overall, this was a fantastic story that took some really interesting turns and kept me engaged. It deserved to be much much longer.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a website or blog at WordPress.com

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: